Which protection relay is best for a PLC & Automation Control Panel?

The best relay depends on the load and protection function required. For feeder and motor circuits, multifunction relays with overcurrent, earth-fault, phase loss, and thermal overload protection are commonly used. For generator or critical utility panels, add reverse power, under/overfrequency, and synch-check functions. Popular product families include Siemens SIPROTEC, ABB Relion, Schneider Electric Easergy, and SEL relays. Selection should be based on the panel’s control voltage, CT/VT inputs, communication protocol, and the assembly’s rated short-circuit withstand as defined by IEC 61439-1 and IEC 61439-2. In automation panels, Modbus TCP, Profinet, or Ethernet-based diagnostics are often preferred for SCADA integration.

How do you integrate protection relays in an IEC 61439 panel?

Integration starts with verifying the relay’s auxiliary supply, terminal ratings, and heat dissipation against the enclosure design. Under IEC 61439-1 and IEC 61439-2, the complete assembly must be verified for temperature rise, dielectric properties, clearances, creepage, and short-circuit performance. Mount the relay with adequate ventilation, segregate CT wiring from power cabling, and coordinate inputs/outputs with PLC digital I/O, trip circuits, alarm contacts, and breaker shunt trips. If the relay communicates to SCADA or BMS, ensure the network architecture and EMC layout support reliable operation. The relay must also be coordinated with upstream ACBs or MCCBs and downstream motor starters.

What standards apply to protection relays in automation control panels?

The main assembly standard is IEC 61439-1/2 for low-voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies, which governs verification of temperature rise, dielectric strength, short-circuit withstand, and protective circuits. The relay’s device-level performance is typically covered by the IEC 60947 series, depending on its function and associated switching devices. If the panel serves hazardous areas, IEC 60079 may apply to the installation environment. In some arc-flash or arc-fault containment applications, IEC 61641 is referenced for internal arc test considerations. For communication and interoperability, many relays support industrial protocols such as Modbus, Profinet, or IEC 61850, but the standards above govern the electrical safety and assembly compliance.

How do protection relays coordinate with MCCBs and ACBs?

Coordination is achieved by matching pickup settings, time-current curves, and breaker trip characteristics so that the device nearest the fault clears first. In a PLC & Automation Control Panel, the relay may issue a trip to an MCCB or ACB via a shunt trip or undervoltage release, while the breaker provides the interrupting capacity. The relay settings must be coordinated with upstream devices to maintain selectivity and minimize process interruption. This is especially important in systems with VFDs, soft starters, and critical motor loads. The assembly short-circuit rating must also remain valid for the chosen combination, as required by IEC 61439 verification principles.

Can protection relays be used with VFDs and soft starters?

Yes, but the settings and measurement method must be appropriate. For VFD-fed motors, a standard thermal overload relay may not work correctly because inverter waveforms, harmonics, and switching behavior affect current measurement. A multifunction protection relay or a drive-compatible motor protection unit is often preferred. For soft starters, the relay must avoid nuisance trips during ramp-up while still detecting genuine overloads and faults. In both cases, CT placement, filtering, and trip thresholds should be coordinated with the drive manufacturer’s recommendations. The panel designer must also account for heat rise, wiring segregation, and the assembly verification requirements of IEC 61439-1/2.

What short-circuit rating should a protection relay have in a control panel?

A protection relay itself usually does not set the panel short-circuit rating; the complete assembly does. However, the relay must be suitable for the fault energy and associated control circuit conditions. The panel’s declared short-circuit withstand rating may be 25 kA, 36 kA, 50 kA, or higher depending on the supply and upstream protective devices. Under IEC 61439, the busbars, wiring, terminals, and protective devices must be verified for this value. The relay must also survive transient overvoltages, CT saturation, and trip circuit stress without losing functionality. In practice, designers verify both the panel SCCR and the relay’s own withstand and insulation ratings.

How much heat do protection relays add to a PLC panel?

Protection relays typically add modest heat compared with VFDs, contactors, or power supplies, but their contribution still matters in dense automation panels. High-end relays with displays, communication modules, and energized outputs can add measurable thermal load, especially when several are installed in a single enclosure. IEC 61439-1 requires the designer to verify temperature rise of the assembly, so relay placement, ventilation, spacing, and ambient temperature must be considered. Avoid locating relays directly above major heat sources such as drives or transformer sections. If the panel uses Form 3 or Form 4 separation, route airflow and wiring carefully to maintain both thermal performance and service access.

What communication options do modern protection relays support in SCADA-ready panels?

Modern protection relays commonly support Modbus RTU, Modbus TCP, Profibus, Profinet, EtherNet/IP, and in utility or substation-style applications IEC 61850. The right choice depends on the PLC platform, SCADA architecture, and cybersecurity requirements. In a PLC & Automation Control Panel, Ethernet-based protocols are often preferred because they integrate directly with PLCs, HMIs, historian systems, and remote diagnostics tools. Communication is especially useful for event logs, fault records, power quality data, and condition monitoring. Even when a relay is communication-ready, the panel designer must still meet the EMC, segregation, and wiring rules under IEC 61439.

Panel + Component

Protection Relays in PLC & Automation Control Panel

Protection Relays selection, integration, and best practices for PLC & Automation Control Panel assemblies compliant with IEC 61439.

Overview

Protection relays in a PLC & Automation Control Panel are the intelligence layer that coordinates fault detection, selectivity, and safe shutdown across motors, feeders, transformers, and process utilities. In modern automation panels, these devices are typically mounted alongside PLCs, MCCBs, contactors, VFDs, soft starters, control power supplies, and industrial Ethernet switches, but they must be selected not only for function, but also for thermal performance, EMC robustness, wiring segregation, and compatibility with the assembly declaration under IEC 61439-1 and IEC 61439-2. In practice, protection relays may provide overcurrent, earth-fault, overload, phase failure, under/overvoltage, frequency, reverse power, generator, motor, feeder, and differential protection, often with communication via Modbus RTU, Modbus TCP, Profibus, Profinet, EtherNet/IP, or IEC 61850 for integration with SCADA, BMS, and asset-monitoring platforms. For PLC and automation applications, the relay’s CT and VT inputs, auxiliary supply, and output contacts must be coordinated with the panel’s rated operational voltage, control circuit design, and short-circuit rating. Engineers should verify the relay’s withstand capability against the declared panel short-circuit current, for example 25 kA, 36 kA, 50 kA, or higher depending on the incoming supply and upstream protective device. The relay itself is not the limiting factor; the complete assembly must satisfy the short-circuit verification method in IEC 61439, including the busbar system, outgoing devices, terminal blocks, and wiring. Selectivity with upstream ACBs or MCCBs and downstream motor feeders is essential to avoid unnecessary plant downtime. Typical configurations include protection relays used with CT ratios such as 100/5 A, 250/5 A, or 400/5 A for feeder and motor circuits, with configurable curves and pickup thresholds to protect DOL starters, star-delta starters, soft starters, and VFD-driven loads. For VFD-fed motors, the relay must be chosen carefully because harmonics, switching transients, and motor cable lengths can affect nuisance tripping and measured values. In hazardous areas or special process zones, the assembly may also need to consider relevant requirements from IEC 60079 for explosion-protected installations, while arc-fault containment testing or mitigation may reference IEC 61641 where applicable to the enclosure or application. From a panel-building perspective, the relay’s footprint, terminal accessibility, display visibility, and heat dissipation must fit within the enclosure temperature-rise limits defined by IEC 61439-1/2. Adequate spacing, cable duct planning, and segregation from power conductors are important to preserve measurement accuracy and EMC performance. Form of separation, such as Form 2, Form 3, or Form 4 arrangements, may be used to improve maintainability and fault isolation in larger automation panels, especially where multiple process sections, redundant PLCs, and independent safety functions coexist. Protection relays from well-known product families such as Siemens SIPROTEC, ABB Relion, Schneider Electric Easergy, or SEL relays are often specified where advanced diagnostics, event logs, and time-stamped fault records are required. The best installations align relay settings with the overall protection philosophy, coordination study, and panel documentation package, including single-line diagrams, I/O schedules, wiring schematics, and test records. When correctly integrated, protection relays improve uptime, simplify troubleshooting, and provide a more resilient PLC & Automation Control Panel architecture for manufacturing lines, water treatment plants, HVAC plants, energy systems, and infrastructure automation.

Key Features

Protection Relays rated for PLC & Automation Control Panel operating conditions
IEC 61439 compliant integration and coordination
Thermal management within panel enclosure limits
Communication-ready for SCADA/BMS integration
Coordination with upstream and downstream protection devices

Specifications

Panel Type	PLC & Automation Control Panel
Component	Protection Relays
Standard	IEC 61439-2
Integration	Type-tested coordination

Back to Hubs

PLC & Automation Control Panel

Protection Relays

Frequently Asked Questions

Need a Custom Panel Built to Spec?

Patrion's engineering team designs and manufactures IEC 61439 compliant panels. Get a design review or quote.

Contact Patrion Call +90 232 332 22 78